I find Ian's clarification helpful here., and I think this message was meant
for the list.
----- Original Message -----
From: Ian Hunt <Ian.Hunt@flinders.edu.au>
To: Michael J Williams <email@example.com>
Sent: Monday, September 06, 1999 1:29 AM
Subject: Re: [OPE-L:1111] Re: Re: Re: Unproductive labour income andMarxian
social accounts, part 2
> >> How does Marx define a service ? "A service is nothing other than the
> >> USEFUL EFFECT of a use-value, be it that of a commodity, or that of the
> >> labour" (Cap I, chapter 7, section 2). Note that a service is not
> >> use-value.
> >This quote alone does not enable your categorical conclusion. It asserts
> >that a service may be a useful effect of the use value of labour. And
> >is, imo, a bit of a tangle. First because, for Marx (as you go on to
> >out), it is labour power (if anything) not labour that is a commodity,
> >it is a commodity that has a use-value. So, whether a service has a
> >use-value is part of the question at issue as to whether a service is a
> Marx can regard labour - ie, a concrete labour - as a commodity, as well
> labour power. What cannot be a commodity for Marx is socialy necessary
> ABSTRACT labour.
> We can then distinguish between commodities that are consumed at the point
> of production, that are called "services", and vendible commodities - ie
> labour crystallised in some enduring material body.
> I think there are two notions of 'productive" at work in Marx. Labour
> exchanged against capital, and capital good producing labour. The second
> not too useful, as I see it.
> Dr Ian Hunt,
> Associate Professor in Philosophy,
> Director, Centre for Applied Philosophy,
> Philosophy Dept, School of Humanities,
> Flinders University of SA,
> Humanities Building,
> Bedford Park, SA, 5042,
> Ph: (08) 8201 2054 Fax: (08) 8201 2556
Dr Michael Williams
Economics and Social Sciences
De Montfort University
[This message may be in html, and any attachments may be in MSWord 97. If
you have difficulty reading either, please let me know.]
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Sun Feb 27 2000 - 15:27:08 EST