Re: [OPE-L] sundry

Date: Sun Sep 03 2006 - 14:52:13 EDT

I have seen no evidence -- whatsoever -- that Stavros or _Science & Society_
illegitimately "appropriated" your perspectives on Grossmann.  While it is
not my place to speak for Stavros and David L, I believe they have not
responded on the list because they do not believe it is worth a response.
Moreover, it should be noted that  not a single person on the list has
come forward and supported your claim or even asked SM and/or  DL to reply
to your charges. In other words, no one believes you.

Please immediately cease and desist making claims of improprieties
without proof.   If you want to see the matter discussed further,
then you can take it up with the editors of _Science & Society_,
not on OPE-L.

In solidarity, Jerry

> ps since you want to be moderator for life, I think you should attend
> to my concerns about the Science and Society exchange.

> If scholars can get
> away with appropriating ideas  expressed on OPE-L without
> acknowledgement,  then fellow members of OPE-L will be less likely to
> engage in debate here. This appropriation  is an active threat to
> this list, and Stavros and David Laibman  have not responded to my
> complaints.
> So please do your self appointed job.

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Sat Sep 30 2006 - 00:00:06 EDT