[OPE-L:4963] Re: Re: RE: causes of changes in prices of production

From: Gerald_A_Levy (Gerald_A_Levy@email.msn.com)
Date: Mon Feb 19 2001 - 10:18:32 EST

In [OPE-L:4962] Paul Z wrote:

>  <snip, JL>  But Fred hasn't answered Andrew's 4929 > below as far as I
can see.
> It's a tough question, maybe even unanswerable.  In any > case, oughtn't
> Fred to try to take a position on this question?  Andrew > once asked me
> same question on another topic, and I told him I didn't > know the answer
> and I still don't; I'm hoping to learn if there a way to
> answer such a
> question.

Fred  *DID* answer, in [OPE-L:4932], the question that Andrew asked.  Indeed
in Andrew's reply in [OPE-L:4937], he recognized this as an answer: "Well,
finally, an answer. Not one I accept, but at least an answer".

In solidarity, Jerry

> "Drewk" <Andrew_Kliman@msn.com> said, on 02/17/01:
> >In reply to Fred's OPE-L 4924:
> >He wrote:  "even if I am mistaken about market prices and the rate of
> >profit in Chapter 6 of Volume 3, this does not affect the validity of my
> >criticism of Andrew's
> >interpretation of Marx's prices of production."
> >What, in your opinion, WOULD affect the validity of your
> >criticism?  Under what conditions would you be willing to concede that
> >your criticism is indeed invalid?  I really need to know.
<snip, JL>

This archive was generated by hypermail 2b30 : Thu Mar 01 2001 - 14:01:39 EST